The worldwide pandemic has eradicated so many public occasions, and it sucks. Sports activities, canceled. Concert events, canceled. Graduations, canceled. In Louisiana, the place I stay, there are normally a bunch of superior spring festivals; not this 12 months. Additionally canceled, nearly each school- and state-level science honest and, so far as I can inform, just about each Science Olympiad occasion.
At the least for the science festivals and tournaments, that might not be such a nasty factor. I’m a giant fan of science and science schooling, however I wish to recommend that this will likely really be a very good time to step again and replicate just a little on what these occasions have grow to be. Are they doing what we would like them to do? May we make them higher? Ought to now we have them in any respect?
What’s Incorrect With Science Festivals
When you’re not accustomed to science festivals, they’re type of just like the TV present American Idol however with out the singing (although it’s not technically in opposition to the foundations). They’re open to all college students, like the general public auditions for Idol. And there are a number of ranges the place youngsters are eradicated and a few transfer on. There are additionally judges—although, alas, no Randy Jackson to say, “Yo, dawg. That was sizzling.”
As an alternative of singing about love or vehicles, college students should do a track and dance (metaphorically talking) concerning the “scientific technique” and the way it applies to issues like:
- What occurs whenever you put Mentos in soda? (a perennial)
- Do bean crops develop higher with completely different colour lights?
- Are you able to make a battery from a potato? (sure)
- Are metallic baseball bats higher than wooden bats?
Oh, however wait! Actual scientists don’t really comply with that checklist of steps that was posted in your middle-school classroom wall. Actually, science is the method of constructing and testing fashions. However science festivals appear to pressure college students into this synthetic, cookie-cutter presentation format.
After college students accumulate information for his or her challenge, they make a poster to current their findings. It have to be a rule that a minimum of one third of the poster is devoted to “Collect supplies.” And if the poster doesn’t embrace the phrase “My speculation was appropriate,” they most likely will not win. (If I had my method, we’d cease utilizing the phrase speculation in science courses altogether.)
As soon as they get their posters up, college students then should endure the scrutiny of the judges. I have been a decide, and it may be painful. On prime of that, typically they get neighborhood leaders and enterprise individuals to evaluate the occasion, and for all their good intentions, a few of them do not have a lot background in science.
Ultimately, somebody wins first prize, nevertheless it’s typically pretty arbitrary. Typically there are a number of college students with glorious displays. However possibly somebody had a extra colourful poster or a greater oral presentation that sways the judges of their favor.
General, I do not suppose it is the very best expertise. It forces science right into a aggressive framework as if it was a sporting occasion. Science is just not a contest. Science is a collaborative and artistic means of modeling real-world issues—that is it.
On prime of that, I actually do not suppose science festivals promote an understanding of the character of science. For many college students, these occasions do not encourage them or excite them about science. Many courses have a science honest challenge as a requirement within the course. These youngsters are simply there so they will not fail.